Wyckoff Pizza & Restaurant

Wyckoff Pizza & Restaurant, nestled at 525 Cedar Hill Ave in Wyckoff, NJ, is a beloved local gem that has earned a loyal following. Customers rave about the warm and inviting atmosphere coupled with fast, friendly service. A standout feature is their diverse range of pizzas, including highlights like the Grandma's Pie and the Meat Lovers, which are praised for their exceptional flavors and quality ingredients. Many patrons, such as Vincent Brennan, commend the cleanliness and inviting ambiance, often reminiscing about the delightful experience of enjoying a slice—whether in the cozy dining area or on the go. The restaurant's wraps, like the California Club and Buffalo Chicken, also draw attention for their fresh ingredients and hearty portions. Notably, the customer service is frequently highlighted, particularly in situations where kitchen delays arise, as demonstrated by Melissa Barbarisi's commendation of the staff's generosity in providing complimentary slices while waiting for their meals. While there have been a few isolated experiences with burnt pizzas, such as mentioned by Honest Truth, the overwhelming consensus remains that Wyckoff Pizza & Restaurant serves fantastic food and provides a reliable dining option in the community. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or a traditional Italian dish, this spot is worth a visit for any pizza enthusiast.